Played and Rated
Pricing

Ben Feder Predicts 'Toy Story Moment' for AI in Games

Former Take-Two CEO Ben Feder believes a single breakthrough game will overcome Western consumer resistance to generative AI in game development, similar to how Pixar's Toy Story ended skepticism of computer animation.

Former Take-Two CEO Ben Feder believes a single breakthrough game will overcome Western consumer resistance to generative...

Former Take-Two Interactive CEO Ben Feder predicts a 'Toy Story moment' will drive Western consumer acceptance of generative AI in video games. Feder, who oversaw the launch of Grand Theft Auto 4 and Red Dead Redemption, now heads the venture capital fund Tirta Ventures, which is actively investing in AI-first games. This push comes as a recent industry report estimates that 40 percent of developers are already using generative AI tools.

Feder notes that in Eastern markets, generative AI in games is already widely accepted. In the West, however, consumer sentiment remains sour. He states that gamers there are openly hostile to AI, a perception negatively affected by low-quality 'AI slop' games on platforms like Steam, the 'enshittification' of fan wikis, and links to widespread industry layoffs.

Technical Potential vs. Consumer Resistance

Feder compares the potential of generative AI to a past technological leap: Unreal Engine's instancing technology. That innovation enabled Fortnite to support over 100 players per server, fundamentally changing multiplayer gameplay. He believes AI can similarly radically change gameplay, not only reduce production costs.

Incumbent publishers currently focus on using AI for cost reduction, according to Feder. He is more interested in its potential for gameplay innovation. His venture firm evaluates investments by asking if the game's core AI capabilities were possible before and whether the game improves as the underlying AI technology advances.

Strategic Shifts for Publishers

For established publishers, Feder advises a dual strategy. They should protect their core intellectual property, creative talent, communities, and distribution channels. Simultaneously, he recommends establishing smaller, autonomous teams dedicated to experimentation with new AI-driven concepts.

He believes big companies are currently leaning on existing IP and are happy for startups to do the disruptive work, as they can simply acquire successful innovators later. Feder counsels startups to ignore conventional industry wisdom and focus squarely on their audience and the game itself. He states that originality and authentic engagement become more valuable as AI makes content production easier.

The industry faces a key test with the imminent launch of Grand Theft Auto 6. Feder suggests that greenlighting a $300 million game is a five-year process akin to putting a team in a time capsule. He does not believe AI will necessarily reduce those colossal development costs, but sees other advantages for game makers. The key is to use AI to rethink development, not only to automate existing workflows.

Epic Games, the maker of Fortnite and Unreal Engine, is already transforming its engine into one almost entirely driven by generative AI and large language models. Feder believes the current resistance will vanish once the industry produces its defining, breakthrough title. He is convinced the industry is one such moment away from widespread consumer acceptance, just as the success of Toy Story ended resistance to computer-generated animation.

Topics

#Pricing

Related coverage

More from Pricing