Played and Rated
Comparisons

Bloodborne's Fragmented Rights Block Sequel or Remake

Complex rights ownership between PlayStation, FromSoftware, and Kadokawa Corporation has stalled any new Bloodborne project for over a decade, according to former PlayStation executive Shawn Layden.

Complex rights ownership between PlayStation, FromSoftware, and Kadokawa Corporation has stalled any new Bloodborne...

Bloodborne rights ownership issues are the primary obstacle preventing a sequel or remake. More than a decade after its release, the beloved action RPG remains locked in a corporate deadlock that has halted all new development.

Multiple corporate entities hold key rights to Bloodborne, creating a deadlock for any new project. Those rights are split between PlayStation as the original publisher, FromSoftware as the developer, and Kadokawa Corporation as FromSoftware's primary stakeholder. According to former PlayStation head Shawn Layden, getting all parties to sign off on the same project is the biggest challenge. Bloodborne 2 has not been developed due to these complex rights negotiations. The fundamental hurdle is achieving unanimous agreement from Sony, FromSoftware, and its parent company.

Development Roadblocks

Efforts to create a remake or sequel have been blocked by conflicting interests and developer priorities. Bluepoint Games, the studio behind the Demon's Souls remake, reportedly pitched a Bloodborne remake. That pitch was made before PlayStation ultimately shut down the studio. FromSoftware itself reportedly did not want the remake project to proceed. Former Sony executive Shuhei Yoshida has previously speculated that FromSoftware director Hidetaka Miyazaki is interested in the property but is too busy and protective of the project to move forward with external partners.

Historical Context and Past Attempts

Previous successful remakes like Demon's Souls set expectations, but Bloodborne's unique circumstances have stalled progress. The Demon's Souls redux was a successful collaboration between Japan Studio and Bluepoint Games, which naturally led to hopes for similar projects involving Bloodborne. However, Japan Studio, which co-developed the original Bloodborne, was closed in 2020. This removed a key internal advocate and potential development partner from the equation.

Bloodborne was released on PS4 and remains playable on PS5 via backward compatibility. It has maintained stable sales for more than a decade. Despite this enduring popularity, the game has no remaster, no PC port, and no sequel. In a separate media development, a Bloodborne animated feature is in development with popular YouTuber JackSepticEye attached as a co-producer. Layden described working with FromSoftware on Bloodborne and Demon's Souls as a fantastic experience. The hunter's dream remains just that for now.

Related coverage

More from Comparisons